May 26 2018 / Rating: 8.1 / Views: 511

Comparative case study research method - Comparative Case Studies Methodological Briefs- Impact Evaluation No. 9

Third, traditional approaches to case study research understate the value of case studies in social science research.

I aim to help the emerging researchers in the field of education familiarize themselves with the diverse views regarding case study that lead to a vast array of techniques and strategies, out of which they can come up with a combined perspective which best serves their research purpose. The question of researcher subjectivity is a valid one, and it may be intended only as a methodological critique of what are obviously less formalised and methods Verschuren, 2003. This is a quite different of replication design as promoted by Yin and the need for units of analysis that it implies. They seek to disrupt dichotomies, static categories, and notions of what is going on. It encourages us to attend very carefully to the social relations and networks that constitute the most relevant context in one s research and how these relations and networks have formed and shifted over time. NOTE The course is about case studies as a tool for the generation of causal inferences.

The field draws on diverse disciplinary sources including cultural and psychological anthropology, cognitive psychology, clinical psychology, economics, history, international relations, philosophy, political science, political theory, psychology of personality, social psychology, and sociology. This sense, using as an alternative education a profile of organizational culture as a longitudinal case study survey will help to write dissertation submitted in this research situations where. Finally, we consider the work of Sharan publication, Qualitative research and case study applications in education, is widely cited in the education literature. Instead of this a priori bounding of the case, the CCS approach features an iterative and contingent tracing of relevant factors, actors, and features see Bartlett Vavrus 2016. They found research procedures enhancing external validity in 82 of 159 papers, and procedures supporting reliability in 27 of these papers.

Help, ohio and five comparative case study of accent in the dissertation is responsible for smes. An alternative measure of the rigour of case study research focuses on how good the theory is that emerges from this research.

In this article, we argue for a new approach the comparative case study approach CCS that attends simultaneously to macro, meso, and micro dimensions of case-based research. In sum, we question the conflation of phenomenon and context, and we critique their limited notion of context. The following other ECPR Methods School courses could be useful in combination with this one in a training track. Our notion of context also attends to power relations and the critical theories of place and space put forward by critical geographers and abstract id 2301453 Wednesday 3 Goertz, Gary 2006 Social Science Concepts A User s Guide.

Such a theoretical framework can then serve as a compass for the search of a field 2005. Contributions of case studies to theory Case studies can inform the development of more robust theory that identifies the links between problem, intervention and outcome.

Case Study Methods Resources in the Internet APSA s Qualitative and Multi-Methods Section, APSA s Qualitative Methods Newsletters, edu moynihan cqrm Newsletters Center for Qualitative and Multi-Method Inquiry, John Gerring s blog, Andrew Bennett s webpage, Beach and Pedersen on process tracing, You are here Comparative Case Studies Comparative Case Studies Another way of checking if results match the program theory is to use a comparative case study. This helps developing an idea about how case studies are presented and done in empirical research.

One major goal of this session is to encourage the participants to reflect on the specific type of causal relationship they believe to be in place and to formulate their theoretical expectations accordingly.

The third and arguably most prominent critique of single case study analysis is the issue of external validity or

With our more understanding in mind, we should be aware that some studies may be more pre-structured than others the degree of flexibility will depend on the study s aims, the researcher s motivations, skills, and interests, and the available time and resources, among other things. A second qualifier relates to the difference between statistical and analytical generalisation single case studies are clearly less appropriate for the former but arguably retain significant utility for the latter the difference also between explanatory and exploratory, or theory-testing and as discussed above. We will begin by discussing what a case study is and what it is good for.

C research tasks, this course does not focus on the hands-on principles and practices of data collection, such as interviewing, archival research,?

A major and important alternative strategy is to identify and address rival explanations for your findings. In contrast, we argue forcefully for the value of comparison in case study research. It is common to recognize that certain features are within the system, within the boundaries of the case, and other features outside are significant as context. ambitious research design and summarise the lessons I have learnt with broader relevance for comparative case-study research, writes Simone Tulumello Item Type Website Blog Entry Official URL Additional Information 2017 The Author s Subjects Sets Date Deposited 08 Jun 2017 13 46 Last Modified 08 Jun 2017 13 46 URI Actions login required View Item LSE Research Online supports with a base URL of The contribution of case study research to knowledge of how to improve quality of care BMJ Quality Safety This site uses cookies. 2010, Working Together Collective action, the commons, and multiple methods in practice, Princeton University Press, ch. Of these, we feel only an explanatory case rises to the level of significance expected of most social science research.

152-175 This article considers the role of generalization in comparative case studies, using as exemplars the contributions to this special issue on climate change politics.

Tags: #case, #comparative research